Monday, 20 July 2026

Are You an All-Weather or a Fair-Weather Christian?

The Bible makes it clear that suffering is a part of the normal Christian life.

In Romans 8:17, for example, Paul says that Christians are ‘heirs of God and fellow heirs with Christ, provided we suffer with him in order that we may also be glorified with him’ (ESV).

Similarly, in 2 Timothy 3:12 Paul states that ‘all who desire to live a godly life in Christ Jesus will be persecuted’ (ESV).

Or again, in Hebrews 12:7 the author says, ‘It is for discipline that you have to endure. God is treating you as sons. For what son is there whom his father does not discipline?’ And then in v. 11 he adds, ‘For the moment all discipline seems painful rather than pleasant’ (ESV).

There are also many other passages that teach along the same lines. Basically, there is no doubt that suffering is a normal part of Christian experience.

Times of great suffering

Most sufferings we experience are relatively low-level. These are minor problems of all sorts that we have to face on a daily basis, that cause us no more than a small amount of distress. We can expect to experience these almost constantly for the duration of our lives.

But I would suggest that it is also normal for Christians to experience times of great distress now and then. To have times like these often is fairly unusual but never to have such times is also unusual.

Many of the Psalms, for example, were written by David and others, when they were suffering really badly (e.g., Psalms 6, 38, 42, 77). And the New Testament tells us that the Old Testament was written for the instruction of Christians (Rom 15:4). There is no good reason for thinking that it is normal for Christians to go through their entire lives avoiding times of deep distress such as we read about in the Psalms.

So if we are devout followers of Jesus – as, of course, we should be – then there will probably be some times of intense suffering in our lives.

If we understand this, we will be in a much better place to face these times when they occur.

Christians who go to pieces in times of bad weather

We could compare seasons of life to different kinds of weather.

Good weather, or fair weather, is when life is not that difficult, when there are only minor sufferings to be dealt with. Bad weather is when the big sufferings hit.

It is not uncommon to find Christians who do very well in times of fair weather but who go to pieces when the weather turns bad.

In fair-weather times they are models of Christian discipleship, devoting themselves to prayer, Scripture, using their talents, sharing the faith, helping people, etc., etc. They cope reasonably well with the minor problems and sufferings that Christians experience in times of fair weather.

But when the big hits come, the agonies, that’s when their discipleship collapses. Instead of letting their sufferings drive them to God for help in their dire straits, they run away from Him.

These are the people represented by the seed sown on rocky ground in the parable of the different kinds of ground:

And others are like seed sown on rocky ground. When they hear the word, immediately they receive it with joy. But they have no root; they are short-lived. When distress or persecution comes because of the word, they immediately fall away.’ (Mark 4:16-17; CSB)

When the bad weather comes, we need to run towards God

When the weather turns bad and we are in deep distress, for whatever reason, that is the time not to run away from God but to run to Him. He is able and willing to help us, and He will surely do so. I have been able to testify to this myself on many occasions.

Life without God is totally meaningless and hopeless anyway. A godless life is a tragic, empty thing. Running away from God is only going to make things worse for us.

Besides, we each have a need to be rescued from God’s eternal punishment, and only those who endure to the end will be finally saved (Mark 13:13). So quite apart from the fact that life here and now without God will not go well for us, life after death will go infinitely worse if we walk away from Him.

In John 6:66-69 we read about a time when many of Jesus’s followers stopped following Him, and He asked the Twelve if they wanted to do the same. On this occasion Peter gave an excellent reply:

‘Lord, to whom will we go? You have the words of eternal life. We have come to believe and know that You are the Holy One of God.’ (CSB).

All our hopes need to be in God and in reaching fullness of joy in His presence after we die.

Warning new Christians

When people first become Christians, they often have quite an easy time of things to begin with. This doesn’t always happen, but fairly often it does. New Christians can therefore sometimes start to think that the absence of deep suffering is what they can expect for the rest of their lives.

I would suggest that it is helpful for new Christians to be warned that it is normal for believers to experience times of deep distress now and again. If they aren’t told this, they can be devastated when these times arise.

Let’s be determined to keep going

Let us all, then, be clear-eyed about the nature of Christian discipleship. It is normal for followers of Jesus to experience seasons of great suffering now and then. It is normal for the weather to turn bad from time to time.

When this happens, let’s be determined to keep going on the narrow path, following the Lord, regardless of what we face.

 

See also:

Some Things for Christians to Do When They Are Hanging On by Their Fingernails

Charismatic Churches and Their Attitude to Hardship

What to Do If You Feel Like Blaming God for Something

Taking Heart from the Apostle Paul’s Experiences of Setbacks and Failed Plans