Showing posts with label Moral issues. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Moral issues. Show all posts

Thursday, 1 October 2026

Beware of Those Who Seek to Pin the Blame on White People

 As Christians, we need to be clear-eyed about what is going on around us, as far as ideological trends are concerned. Where an evil ideology is gaining ground in popular opinion, we must be careful to avoid being caught up in its mindset. And where appropriate, we need to take a stand against it.

There is an evil ideology that has been gaining ground in the last few decades around the world that I think many Christians are unaware of. It is a racist ideology, and I would suggest that it is now one of the more significant race-hate movements that exist today. Basically, it is the attempt to pin the blame for most of the world’s problems – often for a large majority of the world’s problems – on white people.

This ideology is sometimes called ‘Critical Race Theory’. I won’t use this label myself, because people use it in different ways, and I don’t want to use potentially confusing language. So I will just stick to talking about the attempt to unfairly blame white people for things.

A close parallel with Nazi propaganda

When I have heard supporters of this ideology speak in recent times, the thing that has struck me is the close parallels with Nazi propaganda of the early-mid 20th century.

I don’t know if you have ever seen a video of Adolf Hitler giving a speech in the German parliament in the 1930s. If you have and you have managed to get through it to the end, you won’t have failed to see him spend some time furiously denouncing Jews.

In the Nazi narrative, Jews were the race that was to blame for Germany’s problems and for most of the world’s problems.

This is, of course, a ridiculous thing for the Nazis to have claimed, but claim it they did. And then their well-oiled propaganda machine got to work trying, with a lot of success, to persuade people that it was true.

For Hitler and others to try to convince people that Jews were the ones to blame, they did several things:

First, they ignored all the good things Jews did.

Second, they pointed to the bad things Jews did. (Obviously, Jews, like other racial groups, had their fair share of blame for Germany’s and the world’s problems.)

Third, they added to the list of bad things with lies.

And fourth, they massively downplayed the bad things that non-Jews did.

The result of all this was a picture of a race of evil people that was to blame for Germany’s and most of the world’s problems.

The modern attempt to pin the blame on white people also does all four of these things. It ignores the good things white people do and have done. It focuses on the bad things white people do and have done. It adds to that list with lies. And it massively downplays the bad things non-white people do and have done.

Where this propaganda is successful, the result is hatred for white people, which at times leads even to violence and murder.

It may well be true that at the present time only a small minority of people who buy into this ideology go as far as actually wishing that white people didn’t exist. But this could easily change.

Let’s not forget that at the beginning of the Nazi movement of the last century, relatively few Nazis wanted to go as far as killing Jews. At that time most of them would have been content for Jews simply to be forced out of Germany.

But later, as the propaganda did its work, more and more Nazis were no longer content with just expelling Jews. They wanted them dead. And the same growth of hatred could well happen in the future in connection with the anti-white ideology that exists today.

I am not saying that white people will ever be in as much danger overall as Jews were last century. In most places we have much more safety in numbers. But hatred for white people does have the potential to increase a lot, and so does the number of racially motivated murders.

White people who buy into this ideology

It isn’t just non-white people who help to push this ideology. More than a few white people do so too.

I am not saying that these people are deliberately trying to whip up hatred against their own race. But unwittingly they are helping to do this.

There are many white people, myself included, who look at some of the evil things that members of our race have done in history and are appalled. In and of itself, there is obviously nothing wrong with this. To call evil by its name and hate it is a good thing to do.

However, for some it doesn’t stop at just hating evil. There are many who go further in problematic ways.

Firstly, there are those white people who actually seem to accept some personal guilt for sins their ancestors committed.

However, Ezekiel 18:19-20 is clear that people are not guilty of sins committed by their ancestors. In this passage God says:

‘Yet you say, “Why should not the son suffer for the iniquity of the father?” When the son has done what is just and right, and has been careful to observe all my statutes, he shall surely live. The soul who sins shall die. The son shall not suffer for the iniquity of the father, nor the father suffer for the iniquity of the son. The righteousness of the righteous shall be upon himself, and the wickedness of the wicked shall be upon himself.’ (ESV)

So it is a mistake to see ourselves as guilty of sins that our ancestors committed.

Secondly, many of the white people who are fixated on past sins by members of their own race seem to have the idea that white people have historically been worse than other racial groups.

This is complete nonsense. When history as a whole is taken into account, the truth is where we would expect to find it, that white people have on balance been no better or worse than other racial groups. I would suggest that anyone who reaches any other conclusion cannot remotely be trying to be fair with the data.

The United Nations declaration

The influence of the ideology I am opposing in this article has been considerable.

On 25 March 2026 the United Nations voted to recognise the transatlantic slave trade (t.s.t.) as the gravest crime against humanity in human history.

I think this is an astonishing thing to claim. Of course, the t.s.t. was clearly a major act of great evil that affected millions of people. But there have been hundreds of other similar evil acts in human history.

Why, for example, was the t.s.t. worse than the Nazi holocaust that killed and displaced more people? Why was it worse than the Arab slave trade in black Africans that lasted for more than half a century after the t.s.t. came to an end? Why was it worse than the horrors of the Japanese empire of the last century or the Mongol invasions of Europe or the Aztec practice of breeding captive tribes of people to sacrifice to their gods? And so on, and so on.

It is true that part of the reason for the U.N. vote had to do with the attempt by some countries to get money from European and North American countries as ‘reparations’. But I am sure that in part it was also influenced by the ideology that seeks to pin the blame for things on white people. After all, this is an increasingly fashionable thing to do.

Christians must oppose all racism

As Christians, we need to take our stand against all racism, whether it is against white people or black people or brown people or whoever.

The idea that there is one racial group that is especially to blame for the world’s problems is an evil notion that serves to divide people and encourage hatred, quite apart from the fact that it is utter nonsense.

Let us all, then, have nothing to do with this destructive ideology.

 

See also:

A Christian Perspective on Racism

Most People in Western Countries Completely Misunderstand What Human Beings Are

‘Human Rights’: A Big Idol among Christians Today

The Arrogance and Hypocrisy of Western Society

Wednesday, 2 September 2026

If the Bible Says It, That Is Enough

Something that you may come across from time to time is a Christian asking God for a sign to confirm biblical teaching.

What happens is that the Christian thinks that the Bible teaches something, but because they don’t like what it teaches, they decide that they will obey its teaching if God provides a sign confirming that this is what He wants.

Some examples

As a case in point, I can remember some years ago hearing about a young Christian man and woman who were engaged to be married.

One evening they were feeling amorous and were tempted to sleep together before the wedding. Instead of choosing to resist this temptation and wait until they were married, they decided to pray that God would send someone to tell them not to sleep together if He really didn’t want them to do this.

They then prayed but no one was sent, so they slept together.

A similar situation that sometimes occurs is when a Christian starts to commit a sin, watching expectantly for God to give them a strong warning that they are outside His will, maybe by striking them down with an illness or something like that.

However, to their surprise, nothing seems to happen. The apparent lack of response from God then makes this Christian think that this sin probably isn’t actually a big deal in God’s eyes, and they keep committing it.

Two important points about biblical revelation

These examples highlight a couple of very important points about biblical revelation and Christian living.

Firstly, if the Bible says that something is wrong, that's all we need to know to decide not to do it.

Secondly, if the Bible says that something is wrong, it is a big mistake to expect God to intervene in our lives to confirm this.

We know from life experience, as well as from Scripture, that God allows us to go wrong in many ways. It is true that there are times when He does take action to stop us committing a sin. But there are also many occasions when, in His wisdom, He allows us to commit sins.

So for any Christian to think that a sin can’t be a big deal to God, because He didn’t take action to stop it, makes no sense at all.

Testing God

Asking God for a sign to confirm biblical teaching is not just pointless and foolish. It actually amounts to testing Him.

In Matthew 16:1-4 we read about a time when some Pharisees and Sadducees did this:

‘And the Pharisees and Sadducees came, and to test him they asked him to show them a sign from heaven.

He answered them, “When it is evening, you say, ‘It will be fair weather, for the sky is red.’ And in the morning, ‘It will be stormy today, for the sky is red and threatening.’ You know how to interpret the appearance of the sky, but you cannot interpret the signs of the times. An evil and adulterous generation seeks for a sign, but no sign will be given to it except the sign of Jonah.”

So he left them and departed.’ (ESV)

These Pharisees and Sadducees were asking for a sign to point to something that should already have been obvious. It should have been clear to all who saw and heard Jesus that He was sent by God.

We must note too how strongly Jesus condemns what they were doing. He calls them ‘evil and adulterous’ for seeking a sign.

What these Pharisees and Sadducees were doing is really the same thing that I spoke about above, i.e., asking God for an unnecessary confirmation of something. So this Bible passage should leave us in no doubt that this is something the Lord deeply dislikes.

God will answer our prayers when we ask for something in faith and in line with His will (1 John 5:14-15). But He is hardly at our beck and call to do things that are completely unnecessary. We need to fit in with where He is at rather than expecting Him to go out of His way to pander to our desires. There is something really insulting to the Lord, not to mention arrogant, about asking Him to give unnecessary confirmations of things.

Did God really say that?

In Genesis 2:16-17, we are told that after God created Adam, He said to him:

‘You are free to eat from any tree of the garden, but you must not eat from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, for on the day you eat from it you will certainly die.’ (CSB)

Then in Genesis 3:1 the snake asks Eve, who has clearly learned from Adam what God had said:

‘Did God really say you must not eat the fruit from any of the trees in the garden?’ (NLT)

The snake in this passage represents Satan, so here we see Satan trying to put doubts into the mind of Eve about the truthfulness of something God had said.

In this respect, nothing has changed. Today, just as ever since the days of the first humans, Satan and his subordinates, i.e., evil spirits, continue to lie to God’s people in this way. Revelation 12:9 says that Satan deceives the whole world, and one way he does this is by inciting doubts about what God has said.

If the Bible says that something is wrong, however, that is enough. That is all we need to know to make our decision about how to act. We need to accept what it says and obey it without testing God by asking for confirming signs.

 

See also:

Salvation Is Not by Doing Good but Only Those Who Do Good Will Be Saved

The Importance of Taking Steps to Avoid Temptation

The Radical Nature of the Normal Christian Life

Learning to Discern the Attacks of Evil Spirits

Tuesday, 11 August 2026

How to Respond to the ‘Two Consenting Adults’ Argument Regarding Homosexual Practice

I am sure that, like me, you will have heard people try to justify homosexual practice by using the two-consenting-adults argument, i.e., by saying that if two consenting adults are involved, then what's the harm.

In the thinking of people who use this argument, if someone is not causing distress to another human being, it makes no sense to say that they are doing anything wrong.

A need to respond to this argument

In sharp contrast to secular thinking on sexual morals, the Bible teaches that sex is only appropriate in a marriage relationship between a man and a woman. And it strongly condemns homosexual acts.

However, for people who don’t accept the Bible’s authority, quoting chapter and verse on homosexuality isn’t going to cut any ice.

Of course, if we can persuade people of the truth of the Bible, that is a very worthwhile thing to do. But nevertheless, it would be helpful if we can use some other arguments too.

In what follows, I will give some ideas for how to respond to people who try to justify homosexual practice by using the two-consenting-adults argument. Some of my arguments will assume that God exists, so these particular arguments wouldn’t necessarily have much impact on those who deny His existence. Nevertheless, I think that even these arguments should sometimes help to get through to some people.

Living within the pattern that God designed

One thing we can say to people who use the two-consenting-adults argument is that human beings need to live the way that God made us to live. It is true that He has given us a lot of freedom, but there are limits to this. We need to live within the pattern that He designed.

If we think about homosexuality, the big thing that should strike us immediately about it is that this isn’t what God made. The human body is obviously designed to fit together heterosexually with another body. This is clearly what God created.

I think people know instinctively that there is something unnatural about homosexuality. Of course, many will deny this, and if people are unwilling to listen to the truth, there is only so much we can do to persuade them. But speaking about the design of human beings will sometimes help to get through to people on this issue.

What human beings want is not the key thing

The second point to make about the two-consenting-adults argument is that it puts human beings on a pedestal in a way that doesn’t match reality.

This argument assumes, either consciously or unconsciously, that human beings are in the place of ultimate authority. In other words, it assumes that what people want, and not what God wants, is the key thing.

It is impossible to overstate how wrong this kind of thinking is. The first thing that anyone should ask about any activity is whether God is OK with it. That is infinitely more important than whether a human being is OK with it.

Only if we are sure that God is fine with something, should we then go on to think about human consent.

This is another point that may have some success in getting through to people on the issue of homosexual practice.

Asking what they think about incest

Another approach that I think would be very worthwhile, when responding to people who use the two-consenting-adults argument, is to refer to incest.

If someone says that homosexual practice is fine if two consenting adults are involved, we can ask them if they believe the same about incest, particularly incest involving a parent and an adult child.

If they are horrified, or at least uncomfortable, with incest of this kind, as I think a large majority of people would be, then we can point out that their discomfort shows that the two-consenting-adults argument is hopelessly simplistic. The rightness or wrongness of sexual relationships is a much deeper issue than people who use this argument think it is.

However, it is true that a few might say that they have no objection to incest involving a parent and an adult child. If they do, we can press further and ask them if they would be fine with this kind of incest in their own family. If the person we are talking to is a parent or grandparent themself, it may even be appropriate to specifically refer to their child or grandchild when asking the question.

If the person gets angry and offended by this question, we can say that we agree that these are offensive thoughts and that that is precisely the point. The fact that they are repulsed by these thoughts shows that the two-consenting-adults argument is far too simplistic. Sometimes, two consenting adults in a sexual relationship is a horrifying prospect.

Then we can say that if this is the case with incest, potentially the same could be true of homosexual relationships too.

I think the vast majority of people would be appalled, or at least uncomfortable, about the prospect of incest in their own family between a parent and a child, so this argument should carry some weight. If they can see that incest is a disgusting thing, even when two consenting adults are involved, they might possibly come to see that homosexual practice is just as disgusting, even when two consenting adults are involved.

It is sad to say, however, that if the moral depravity of Western culture continues to increase, we may reach a time not that many years from now when the average man or woman on the street really won’t have a problem with incest between a parent and child. And it may be that those of us who object to this will be attacked as bigots.

Nevertheless, at the present time this appeal to incest is something that I think should make people stop and think.

Speaking in love

Of course, as Christians, when we criticise sinful behaviour, we must always be careful to remember that we ourselves are sinners saved by grace.

We must never look down on unrepentant sinners from some imagined position of superiority. Instead, we need to look horizontally across to people, speaking in love, remembering that we have committed many sins ourselves and that God has chosen to forgive us.

So if we find ourselves in the position of using the sorts of arguments that I have outlined in this article, let us make sure that our hearts are in the right place as we do so.

 

See also:

Answering the Accusations of the LGBTQ Movement

What Attitude Should Christians Have to Homosexuality?

How Serious a Sin Is Sex outside Marriage?

Most People in Western Countries Completely Misunderstand What Human Beings Are

Thursday, 2 July 2026

The Seriousness of the Sin of Hypocrisy

The Gospels make it clear that when the Lord Jesus was on earth, something that really infuriated Him was hypocrisy.

Of course, there is no doubt that Jesus hated, and still hates, all sin with a passion. But hypocrisy is one of the things that clearly made Him especially angry when He was doing His earthly ministry.

What is a hypocrite?

Before going any further, I think it would be good for me to try to give an accurate definition of what a hypocrite is, because a lot of people don’t get this quite right.

Many have the idea that a hypocrite can be defined as someone who does the same thing that they criticise others for doing.

It is true that very often someone who does the same thing that they criticise others for doing is being a hypocrite. But not always.

So, for example, suppose I am driving my car and I make a minor mistake and another driver hoots his horn at me. But suppose too that the next day I am driving again and this time another driver makes a minor mistake and I hoot my horn at him.

So I am criticising the other driver for a mistake that I myself occasionally make. Does that make me a hypocrite? Surely not.

Or suppose that a husband lets his wife down in some small way and she criticises him for what he has done. But suppose too that the next day she lets him down in a small way and this time he criticises her. Does that make him a hypocrite? Surely not.

Instead of defining a hypocrite as someone who does the same thing that they criticise others for doing, I would suggest the following as a definition:

A hypocrite is someone who pretends to be good in a certain way that they know isn’t true.

In other words, a hypocrite is essentially a fake, a fraud. This is unlike the two examples I gave above, where there was no pretence on my part to be a better driver than I am, and where there was no pretence on the part of the husband that he never lets his wife down.

Hypocrisy, then, is about fakery, about pretending to be good in some way, while knowing full well that this is a lie.

Bible passages on hypocrisy

As far as Bible passages on this topic are concerned, Matthew 23 surely stands out. In Jesus’s strong words against the scribes and Pharisees in this chapter, He uses the word ‘hypocrites’ (Greek: hupokritai) no less than six times, as well as the word ‘hypocrisy’ (Greek: hupokrisis) once. And just reading through the chapter, we can feel the anger that Jesus clearly had for the hypocrites that He was talking to.

The scribes and Pharisees Jesus was addressing pretended to be morally upright citizens, but they were a million miles from being that. And they knew it.

Jesus’s words in verses 25-28 give a vivid description of what hypocrisy is and what He thinks of it:

‘Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! For you clean the outside of the cup and the plate, but inside they are full of greed and self-indulgence. You blind Pharisee! First clean the inside of the cup and the plate, that the outside also may be clean.

Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! For you are like whitewashed tombs, which outwardly appear beautiful, but within are full of dead people’s bones and all uncleanness. So you also outwardly appear righteous to others, but within you are full of hypocrisy and lawlessness.’ (ESV)

We can see clearly in this passage what Jesus made of hypocrisy when His earthly ministry was in progress. And there is not a shadow of a doubt that His attitude remains the same today.

The world is full of hypocrites

It seems to me that everywhere I look in the world today there are huge numbers of monumental hypocrites.

For example, take those feminists who claim to be appalled by sexism, but who will seize any chance they can to discriminate against men.

Or we could think of the protestors against the Israeli actions in Gaza, who claim to be outraged at the deaths of civilians there, but who would never dream of protesting against the regimes around the world that kill far more civilians than the Israelis do.

Or again, take those political pundits who claim to be horrified by the erosion of freedom of speech, but whose horror suddenly disappears when people they disagree with are not allowed to speak.

And the list could go on. We live in a world that is crammed full of people who are utter fakes, frauds and hypocrites.

Christians need to be stunningly different

In this context, in this dark world of ours that is full of fakery and deceit, Christians need to be totally different, stunningly different. We need to be who we claim to be, to the nth degree.

Where we have faults, we need to acknowledge them. And where we have principles, we need to put them into practice all the time and without favouritism. Basically, we need to be sincere and without pretence.

In 2 Corinthians 1:12 the apostle Paul says something about this sort of attitude:

‘For our boast is this, the testimony of our conscience, that we behaved in the world with simplicity and godly sincerity, not by earthly wisdom but by the grace of God, and supremely so toward you.’ (ESV)

Similarly, in 2 Corinthians 4:2 he writes:

‘Instead, we have renounced secret and shameful things, not acting deceitfully or distorting the word of God, but commending ourselves before God to everyone’s conscience by an open display of the truth.’ (CSB)

And Joshua’s words in Joshua 24:14 are just as relevant today as they were when they were first spoken over 3000 years ago:

‘Now therefore fear the LORD and serve him in sincerity and in faithfulness.’ (ESV)

Let all of us who are followers of Jesus, then, redouble our efforts to avoid being hypocrites. The Lord requires this of us, and He deserves nothing less.

 

See also:

The Seriousness of the Sin of Pride

How Serious a Sin Is Sex outside Marriage?

Some Steps That Christians Can Take to Avoid Judging People

The Importance of Taking Steps to Avoid Temptation

Monday, 21 April 2025

What Makes a Human Being a Human Being?

I was talking recently to someone who was arguing in support of abortion. She used a couple of arguments to try to make her case, arguments that are often used by pro-abortionists but which I am sure are misguided.

In what follows, I want to mention these arguments and say why I believe they don’t work.

A point about terminology

Pro-abortionists, of course, almost always claim that an unborn baby, at least in the first months inside the womb, is not really a baby. I strongly disagree with that claim.

However, because this article is aimed at convincing those who take a pro-abortionist position or are undecided, it would be a methodological mistake for me to assume something that those I am arguing against wouldn’t accept.

So, for the sake of argument, at times in what follows I will refer to an unborn baby as an entity or an entity in the womb, since these are terms that everyone would agree are correct.

The argument that appeals to viability

The woman I was talking to used an argument that appealed to the so-called viability of the entity in the womb, and it went along the following lines:

Up until about 22 weeks after conception, the entity in the womb would not be able to survive outside the womb. That means that it is incorrect to describe it as a viable human being. Therefore, it is not wrong to deliberately destroy it.

Firstly, it is important to recognise that there is something very arbitrary about this argument. If someone is going to say that the entity needs to be able to survive outside the womb in order to be classed as a human being, why stop there? Why not say that the entity also needs to be able to feed itself in order to be classed as a human being?

A newborn baby, of course, if left to fend for itself would die. To survive, it is completely dependent on another human being to feed it.

So we can divide things up into three stages. At stage 1, in the first months inside the womb, the entity is unable to survive outside the womb. Then stage 2 is reached when the entity is able to survive outside the womb but only if it is fed by someone else. And finally stage 3 is reached when the entity is able to feed itself.

For someone to claim that the entity is not a human being at stage 1 but is at stage 2 is purely arbitrary. This is just plucked out of thin air.

If having a certain level of ability to survive is a factor that determines whether an entity is a human being, there is no more reason for drawing the line at stage 2 than there is for drawing it at stage 1 or stage 3. Simply to assume that stage 1 doesn’t make an entity human but stage 2 does is an unwarranted assumption.

Secondly, to think in terms of the ability of the entity to survive in various circumstances is completely wrongheaded anyway. As God has designed things, in the first months of its life the entity is not supposed to survive outside the womb. At that stage in its life it is supposed to live in the womb and feed through the umbilical cord.  And then after birth God has designed that the entity is dependent on being fed by another human.

The fact that in the early stages of its life the entity can’t survive outside the womb, or the fact that soon after birth it can’t survive without being fed, are beside the point. These things have nothing to do with whether or not the entity should be classed as a human being.

The argument that appeals to suffering mothers

The woman I was talking to also used an argument that appealed to the suffering of some mothers, and it went in the following way:

Some girls get pregnant at a very young age as a result of rape. It would be wrong to force them to go through the trauma of a pregnancy and having a baby they don’t want. Therefore, in such cases it is not wrong to deliberately destroy the entities in their wombs.

On this point I want to make it clear that I shudder just to think of what these girls would go through having a baby. I have no desire to treat lightly the horrendous suffering involved. But nevertheless, I strongly disagree that it would be OK for girls in this situation to have an abortion.

I asked the woman I was talking to what her view was if a young rape victim gave birth to a baby and was then deeply traumatised and strongly wished the baby was dead. I asked her if she would approve of killing the baby after it was born, and she said that she wouldn’t.

I then asked her why she took this view, and she said that it was too late at that point to kill the baby.

Her answer showed that her top priority was not to protect the young girl from suffering, that there was some other calculation that was even more important. In other words, despite the suffering of the poor girl, the woman I was talking to believed that it was just wrong to kill a newborn baby. The baby was simply too valuable, and it was simply too late to kill the baby, regardless of how much the girl wanted the baby to die.

But suppose, for a moment, that what anti-abortionists like myself believe about the entity before birth is correct, when we say that this entity is a human being. If that is right, then it should be obvious that avoiding killing it should trump the desire to stop the young girl suffering, just as is the case with a baby that has been born.

So the issue of whether the entity in the womb is a human being is the key issue. The issue of the suffering of the rape victim, though very important, is not remotely as important as the issue of whether the entity in the womb is a human being. That is the key issue that trumps any issue of suffering.

The point I am making is that the issue of whether the entity in the womb is a human being is so important that it makes all arguments to do with the suffering of the mother irrelevant. So arguments supporting abortion based on the suffering of some mothers are completely beside the point.

What makes a human being human?

I have already said that the ability to survive outside the womb and the ability to feed oneself have nothing to do with whether an entity should or should not be described as a human being. So what does make an entity human? What is a human being?

I would suggest that the answer to this question is really very simple. A human being is an entity that has a soul made in the image of God.

Now, there should be no doubt that immediately before a baby is born it already has a soul, and few people calling themselves Christians would dispute this. But if it already has a soul before birth, it makes sense to think that the joining of the soul to the material part of the human occurs at some critical point. However, before birth the only really critical point that exists is conception.

If we were to say that the soul joins to the fertilised egg or embryo or foetus at some time after conception but before birth, what reason would we give for taking this view? Why would we think that the soul joins after the physical component of the human has been growing for a week? Or why would we think this happens after 10 days or after 20 or 40?

Crucially, nothing critical happens at these times. But, by contrast, the time the sperm fertilises the egg is a real critical point, and this is surely the time at which the soul joins the physical part of the human. When else could it be?

Thinking, then, that the tiny size of a human fertilised egg in the first few days after conception means that it is not really a human being doesn’t make sense. In fact, a human being with a human soul made in the image of God is present, despite the tiny physical size of the entity in question.

 

See also:

Does the Oral Contraceptive Pill Cause Abortions?

How Serious a Sin Is Sex outside Marriage?

The Arrogance and Hypocrisy of Western Society

Divorce and Remarriage Are Only Acceptable in Special Circumstances

Friday, 21 March 2025

Sometimes Criticising Victims Is the Right Thing to Do

You will quite often hear people objecting whenever someone criticises the victim of an accident or assault. They see ‘victim-shaming’, as they call it, always to be unloving and out of place.

Of course, if someone is a victim through no fault of their own, it would be completely wrong to criticise that person. Or, if the victim was at fault in some way but has seen the error of their way, speaking critically to them would be unnecessary.

However, sometimes people become victims of accidents or assaults because they have done something wrong and they are not willing to admit that it was at all their fault. In such cases, criticising the victim, with the aim of making them feel regret for what they did, is often a loving thing to do.

The benefit of feeling regret

It should be very obvious that for anyone to feel regret for any sin they have committed is a good thing. Regret helps to foster an attitude of repentance and discourages the sinner from repeating the sin.

We see this sort of thinking in 2 Corinthians 7:9-10, where the apostle Paul writes:

‘As it is, I rejoice, not because you were grieved, but because you were grieved into repenting. For you felt a godly grief, so that you suffered no loss through us. For godly grief produces a repentance that leads to salvation without regret, whereas worldly grief produces death.’ (ESV)

There is no need for me here to discuss the details of the situation in Corinth that Paul is referring to in this passage. What is important for our purposes in this article is that he clearly sees the benefit of regret as it leads to repentance. He refers specifically to ‘godly grief’, but this is really just another way of describing regret that God approves of and uses for good.

Of course, feeling regret leads to repentance from all sorts of sins, whether or not a sinner is the victim of an accident or an assault, but sins that lead to being a victim are certainly included in this.

Dangerous driver

Here are some examples of where criticising victims, to try to make them regret what they have done, would be a helpful and positive thing.

Firstly, suppose there is a 17-year-old boy who has just learned to drive. His ego gets the better of him, and he thinks he is a much better driver than he really is. So he drives far too fast on a winding road, crashes his car and breaks his leg.

He is the victim of an accident that was entirely his fault.

Now, immediately after this accident, it would be wrong to speak critically to him. At that time, he needs a ton of sympathy and support.

Also, later on, if he has clearly learned his lesson and sees how stupid he was, there is no good reason for approaching him to criticise him.

But suppose that after a few months it seems obvious that he hasn’t learned his lesson. He is bragging to his friends about crashing his car, treating his broken leg like some sort of a war wound.

In a situation like this, if someone can get this young man to regret what he did, it will be a very helpful thing to do.

If he doesn’t reach the point of feeling regret, there is a real possibility that he might do it again, and maybe next time he might die or be permanently injured or kill someone else. Or he might influence a friend to drive in the way he did.

So he is a victim, and it is good for him to be criticised for the sin he committed – in this case, driving recklessly – that led to him being a victim. Love is sometimes tough, and in this case criticising the victim for the purpose of making him feel regret would be an example of tough love.

Disobedient boy

As another example, suppose there is a 10-year-old boy, and his parents say to him:

‘There are lots of great places around here where you can play with your friends. But don’t go to that park over there, because there are often bigger boys there, bad boys, who might hurt you.’

Suppose that this boy then, for no good reason, disobeys his parents, goes to the park, and is beaten up by the bigger boys.

He is the victim of an assault that was partly his fault.

When I say that it was partly his fault, I hope it is clear that I am not trying to reduce the guilt of the attackers. The guilt of the attackers is a separate thing from the guilt of the boy who committed a sin to put himself in the position where he was attacked. These are separate sins. But in the overall picture of what happened, it is still right to say that it is partly his fault. If he hadn’t disobeyed his parents, he wouldn’t have been beaten up.

Immediately after this assault, it would be wrong to speak critically to this boy. At that time, he needs a lot of comfort and support.

Also, if he has learned his lesson, there would be no place for speaking critically to him at a later time either.

But suppose that after a couple of months it is clear that he hasn’t learned his lesson. He has again disobeyed his parents by going back to that park, risking another beating. In this case, trying to make this boy regret what he did that led to him being beaten up would be a positive thing, both for himself and for any of his friends who might be badly influenced by him.

This is another example, then, of where criticising a victim is a form of tough love.

Sexual assault

Another good example has to do with people, especially young women, who go out drinking and are sexually assaulted because they are too drunk to make good decisions to protect themselves.

Of course, many sexual assaults occur through no fault of the victim. But there are many other occasions, when the victim is partly at fault, because they wouldn’t have been assaulted if they hadn’t committed the sin of getting drunk.

Again, I want to stress that when I say it is partly the victim’s fault, I am in no way trying to reduce the guilt of the attacker. The guilt of the attacker is a separate thing from the guilt of the person who committed a sin to put themself in the position where they were sexually assaulted. These are separate sins. But in the overall picture it is still right to say that in cases like these the victim is partly at fault.

Of course, immediately after the trauma of a sexual assault, the last thing that anyone should do is speak critically to the victim. At that time they need an ocean of sympathy and support.

I also think that a large majority of people who are sexually assaulted because they get drunk do learn their lesson. But if they don’t and they go out drinking heavily again, criticising them to try to make them feel regret would be a good thing to do. In such cases, this would be an example of tough love, both for their own benefit and the benefit of anyone they might negatively influence.

Just as a little side note on this issue, I would advise anyone who goes out on a Friday or Saturday night to have one or at the most two drinks. And I am sure that if young people followed this advice, the number of sexual assaults would decrease, probably by a lot.

As another little side note, I also want to say that it angers me when those who claim to be outraged at sexual assaults refuse to advise people to drink in moderation, even though they must know that doing this would decrease the number of these awful events.

Criticising the actions of those who are repentant

I have already said that if someone is at fault, partly or entirely, for becoming a victim, but is repentant and has learned their lesson, there is no place for approaching them to criticise them.

However, even if they are repentant, there is still a place for sometimes criticising their actions when speaking to other people. If others might be tempted to commit similar sins and also become victims, anything we can say to discourage that behaviour would be helpful.

 

See also:

The Importance of Sympathy and Empathy in Christian Living

Christians Should Expect to Offend People

Some Steps That Christians Can Take to Avoid Judging People

Should Christians Forgive Those Who Are Unrepentant?

Tuesday, 3 September 2024

Is It Wrong for Christians to Attend a ‘Gay Wedding’?

Not so long ago a big controversy arose in evangelical circles, when the Scottish church leader Alistair Begg said that it wasn’t wrong for Christians to attend the ‘gay wedding’ of a relative or friend.

Begg was not claiming that God actually recognises such events as real weddings. Nor was he claiming that homosexual practice is not sinful. Rather, he reasoned that Christians need to love everyone, including unrepentant sinners, and that attending the ‘gay wedding’ of a relative or friend was a way of doing this.

A ‘gay wedding’ is a terrible thing

Before going any further, we need to take a moment to think through what God makes of so-called ‘gay weddings’.

When Paul is outlining the depth of human sinfulness in the early chapters of Romans, homosexual practice is one of the few things he gives more than a passing mention to (Rom 1:26-27). Similarly, 1 Corinthians tells us that those who engage in homosexual practice will not inherit the kingdom of God (1 Cor 6:9-10), which means that they will end up in hell, not heaven, unless they repent and are saved. And in the book of Revelation we read of the sexually immoral, who should be understood to include practising homosexuals, being thrown into the lake of fire (Rev 21:8).

In God’s sight, then, homosexual practice is certainly an awful thing. But a so-called ‘gay wedding’ is an even higher level of evil. Not only do those who support such events condone immoral and unnatural behaviour, but they also dare to start trying to alter God’s pattern of marriage. In effect, they are attempting to tear up God’s blueprints for the marriage relationship and to make better ones to replace them. This is an extremely arrogant thing to do.

Actions often imply things

With the depravity of so-called ‘gay weddings’ in mind, we are now ready to ask if it is OK for Christians to attend them.

To begin with, we should be clear that it is absolutely right for us to seek to love relatives or friends who have a ‘gay wedding’. It is all too common to find Christians acting coldly and unlovingly towards people who are unrepentant of various sins, but this is wrong.

Nevertheless, real love manifests itself in different ways depending on the circumstances. And when people are doing something, like having a ‘gay wedding’, that is displeasing to God and also working strongly towards their own harm, if we do or say things that will help to reinforce the bad decision they have made, that is actually an unloving thing to do.

We need to understand that a ‘gay wedding’ has been organised as a celebration. But it is unthinkable that a Christian could go to one and celebrate what is going on. God is being insulted, and the right response for Christians is to mourn what is happening.

However, our actions often imply things about what we believe, and if we go to a ‘gay wedding’, everyone who sees us there will think that we are celebrating unless we make it clear that we aren’t.

If we don’t make this clear, then we will be playing a part in reinforcing the beliefs of those present that something worth celebrating is taking place. And that means that we would in effect be promoting evil.

Of course, if we were to go and make a visible protest against what is happening, there would obviously be no promotion of evil. However, I think at least usually that would be a very bad idea. Those involved would very probably just be annoyed rather than influenced for good.

The issue of honesty

There is also the issue of honesty to consider. At a ‘gay wedding’ there would surely be speeches commending the couple and expressing support for their decision to have a homosexual union. But how could we honestly clap after a speech of this sort? And when someone raises a glass to toast the couple, again with implied support for what they are doing, how could we raise our own glass with a clear conscience?

Without making a visible protest, which would very probably be a mistake as I have said, it seems impossible to be honest and also go to a celebration if we are mourning. And if two men or two women are planning to have a ‘gay wedding’, we should be mourning deeply.

Joining a neo-Nazi group

Let’s think for a moment about an event that is similar to a ‘gay wedding’.

Suppose you have a relative or friend who is formally joining a neo-Nazi group, a genuine neo-Nazi group that goes as far as wanting the murder of Jews.

Suppose too that a celebration has been organised by this group to mark the occasion. People are going to be wearing suits and dresses, there is going to be champagne and speeches, etc.

Would you really go along to this event, when someone you love is being initiated into a group that supports murder? Would you clap after the speeches that praise the murder of Jews? Would you raise your glass to toast the new neo-Nazi member?

I think the vast majority of Christians wouldn’t do this. More than that, I think they would be horrified at the thought of doing so. They would rightly see that neo-Nazi ideology is a terrible thing and that a celebration admitting a new member to this evil group is something that they just couldn’t be part of.

But in terms of the evil involved, is there really much of a difference between this and a ‘gay wedding’? I suppose we could argue that because neo-Nazis support murder, it is worse than a ‘gay wedding’. But even so, this difference is just a matter of degree, and I think a ‘gay wedding’ would come a close second anyway. It is a massive insult to God.

A poor understanding of how evil a ‘gay wedding’ is

I suspect that the real reason many Christians would choose to go to a ‘gay wedding’ is because they simply don’t understand how evil it is. I think many modern Christians have been unconsciously influenced by the values of mainstream Western culture in this respect.

I would suggest too that the reason why many Christians don’t recognise the evil involved is because they have a human-centred, and not God-centred, worldview. A ‘gay wedding’ doesn’t seem to hurt anyone, so they think it can’t be that bad.

However, the whole starting point for this kind of thinking is wrong. We shouldn’t start by asking whether something hurts other people but whether it hurts God. God is at the centre of the universe. Human beings are not.

Summing up

We should have no hesitation in saying, then, that it is a mistake for Christians to attend a so-called ‘gay wedding’. If we were to go without making it clear that we are deeply opposed to what is going on, our actions could only serve to reinforce the people involved in their bad choices. In any case, it seems very dishonest to give an appearance of supporting a celebration when we oppose it. And it just makes no sense for someone to go to a celebration of something they are in fact mourning.

If we refuse to go to a ‘gay wedding’, there is certainly a place for explaining to others why we can’t be a part of the celebration. And there is also a place for us to affirm our love for the men or women involved. Alistair Begg is quite right about the need to love family members or friends who are doing this.

But if we are putting God first and if we want to do what is right for the people involved, we should steer clear of any celebration connected to this evil act.

 

See also:

What Attitude Should Christians Have to Homosexuality?

What Did Jesus Make of Homosexual Practice?

Answering the Accusations of the LGBT Movement

Most People in Western Countries Completely Misunderstand What Human Beings Are